Short answer: hire a freelancer when the project is clear in scope and one skilled person can do it. Hire an agency when it needs several specialists at the same time or a guaranteed team behind it. I am a freelancer, so I have a side here. I have tried to write this the way I would explain it to a friend.
Side by side
| Freelancer | Agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Who does the work | The person you talk to | A team, often through an account manager |
| Cost | Usually lower: you pay for one person's time | Usually higher: you also pay for management and overheads |
| Speed to start | Often quick, if they are available | Often needs a proposal and scheduling |
| Range of skills | One person's, sometimes wide, never everything | Designers, developers, writers and marketers under one roof |
| Capacity | Limited to one person's hours | Can put more people on a deadline |
| If someone is ill or leaves | The project waits | Someone else can pick it up |
| Communication | Direct | More structured, with more people involved |
When a freelancer is the better choice
- A business website, a landing page or a brand identity
- An MVP or a first version of a web app
- You want to talk to the person doing the work
- The budget does not stretch to agency rates
- You can decide quickly and do not need a large process
When an agency is the better choice
- The project needs design, development, content and marketing running at the same time
- The deadline is fixed and the work is more than one person can do
- Your company requires contracts, insurance or support terms that only a larger supplier offers
- You need a team on call for years, not weeks
The risk with each, and how to reduce it
With a freelancer the risk is dependence on one person. Reduce it by making sure you own the code, the design files and the accounts from the first day, and by asking for regular written updates.
With an agency the risk is that the senior people who sold the project are not the ones who build it. Ask who will do the work and whether you can speak to them.
Questions to ask before you hire either
- Can I see work like mine that you have done?
- Who exactly will do the work?
- What is included in the price, and what counts as extra?
- How often will I see progress?
- Who owns the code, the design and the accounts?
- What happens after launch if something breaks?
How I work
I am one person covering design and development, which suits websites, brand identities, dashboards and first versions of SaaS products. If your project needs a full team, I will say so. My case studies show the kind of work I take on, and my services page lists what I offer.
About the author. Kenil Vaghasiya is a freelance full stack web developer, Framer developer and designer with 5+ years of experience building web applications with React, Next.js, Node.js, .NET and Azure. He works remotely from Surat, India. More about me · Services